Welcome back!



Forgot password?

Don’t have an account? Subscribe now

Ethical vs Criminal: Recording a telephone interview

Trust me on this, I do not like writing pieces on recording a telephone case interview because I really have better things to do than call out the behavior of a minority of readers. And it is just a minority. Yet, Firmsconsulting defines itself by its excessively high standards of conduct so this is worth briefly discussing and sharing as a teaching point for others.

Over the last 3 weeks, no less than 16 readers have written to me asking for guidance on improving their performances in case interviews. With all the innocence of a baby glibly eating Purity, they offered to share a recording of the phone interview.

Do you see the problem? I hope you do.

I would like to remind readers of a few points. This is not an ethics discussion. We only need to have a discussion about being ethical when the law is not clear about an act and we, therefore, need to use our judgment to decide if it is right or wrong.

The law has been clearly written about the surreptitious recording of telephone conversations and it is quite clear: recording a conversation without the consent of the other party is a felony offence.

Not a childish prank.

Not a mistake.

Not a misdemeanor.

It is a felony offence.

Let that sink in.

I agree that it is easy to record a call and maybe you should be allowed to do it. Yet, neither the ease of executing an act nor your personal disagreement with standing criminal codes should allow you to ignore the latter.

Moreover, just because others are doing it does not make it right. The law does not regard mass stupidity as a reasonable defense and all it takes is one firm to prosecute this to make you a poster child for singular stupidity.

As I rightfully pointed out to one reader who wrote in and generously offered me to listen to his call, I am not sure I want to help someone who nonchalantly breaks the law to gain access to the highest corridors of corporate power. Scratch that, I am very sure.

One can only imagine what they will do with client information to accelerate their careers.

In hindsight, I may have been too lenient in the way we handled this. I do not expect readers to not make mistakes. I do not expect readers to be perfect. You will make a lot of mistakes and that is perfectly normal. In fact, your life will be a tapestry of fairly dumb mistakes. That is how we learn.

It is, however, not acceptable to willingly and knowingly commit such a breach of the criminal code and the values we teach. You can be better than that and you should be better than that. If you do not like the law, sue someone and let it wind its way to the Supreme Court.

Whenever, I see someone with great promise make this mistake, I make them read this article.

Promise is easily destroyed when the greed of success takes control of your brain. If you need to commit a felony to become a management consultant, then maybe, just maybe, management consulting is not for you. Management is not about the analytics. It is about honorably deploying the analytics.

Want to learn more about how FIRMSconsulting
can help your organization?

Related Articles

Uncategorized

What Motivates You

What Motivates You? If you’re trying to find better ways to manage your time and be more productive, there’s an exercise that will help you determine what really motivates you. Discovering the core of what drives you to do things will be a much more powerful tool than any time…

Strategy

Don Schmincke: From MIT Planetary Physicist to Training CEOs (Strategy Skills ep. #230)

Don Schmincke: From MIT Planetary Physicist to Training CEOs (Strategy Skills ep. #230) For this episode (#230) of the Strategy Skills Podcast, we interviewed a best-selling author, Don Schmincke. Don is a former MIT and John Hopkins Institute researcher turned organizational strategic development consultant. He's the guy CEOs bring in when many other experts fail. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-q0q2l4ue0&t=2229s…

Strategy

Difficult Conversations at Work: Guidance, Tips and Best Practices

Difficult Conversations at Work: Guidance, Tips and Best Practices You've probably seen the recent headlines about how Vishal Garg, CEO of Better.com, sparked outrage when he laid off 900 employees over a Zoom call. This story became an example of how not to have difficult conversations at work. This circumstance, framed…

We are using cookies on our website

Please confirm, if you accept our tracking cookies. You can also decline the tracking, so you can continue to visit our website without any data sent to third party services.